The Rebellion Against Usability: Why Intuitive UI UX Design is Overrated

More contents: https://axureboutique.com

Axure RP 10 downloads:
Axure Libraries: https://axureboutique.com/collections/libraries
Axure Templates: https://axureboutique.com/collections/templates
Product & UX Tools: https://axureboutique.com/collections/ux
Free Products: https://axureboutique.com/collections/free
Mobile Products: https://axureboutique.com/collections/mobile

In the world of UI UX design, the pursuit of intuitive design has long been considered the holy grail. The idea that a product should be so easy to use that users can effortlessly navigate through it has dominated the industry for years. However, there is a growing rebellion against this notion, with designers and experts arguing that intuitive UI UX design is overrated. In this video, we will explore the reasons behind this rebellion and provide examples to support this perspective.
Complexity and Depth:
One of the main arguments against intuitive UI UX design is that it often sacrifices complexity and depth in favor of simplicity. While intuitive design aims to make interactions seamless and effortless, it can sometimes oversimplify the user experience, limiting the possibilities and depth of engagement. For instance, a photo editing app that offers only basic filters and adjustments may be intuitive, but it fails to cater to the needs of professional photographers who require advanced editing tools.
Learning and Mastery:
Intuitive design assumes that users should be able to understand and use a product without any prior knowledge or training. However, this approach overlooks the value of learning and mastery. Some users enjoy the process of exploring and mastering a complex interface, finding satisfaction in acquiring new skills and knowledge. For example, video game enthusiasts often embrace intricate control schemes and complex gameplay mechanics, as they provide a sense of challenge and achievement.
Personalization and Customization:
Intuitive UI UX design tends to prioritize a one-size-fits-all approach, aiming to cater to the average user. However, this approach overlooks the importance of personalization and customization. Users have different preferences, habits, and workflows, and a rigidly intuitive design may not accommodate their individual needs. For instance, a productivity app that offers limited customization options may hinder users who prefer a highly personalized workflow.
Delightful Complexity:
Sometimes, complexity can be delightful. Certain products and experiences thrive on intricate and non-intuitive designs, creating a sense of discovery and surprise. Take, for example, puzzle games like "The Witness" or escape rooms. These experiences intentionally challenge users with complex puzzles and non-linear paths, providing a sense of accomplishment when they finally solve them. The joy lies in unraveling the complexity, not in intuitive simplicity.
Niche Audiences and Expert Users:
Intuitive UI UX design often caters to the mass market, assuming that users have limited technical knowledge or expertise. However, there are niche audiences and expert users who crave more specialized and intricate interfaces. For instance, software developers rely on complex Integrated Development Environments (IDEs) that may not be intuitive to beginners but offer powerful features and customization options that enhance their productivity.

While intuitive UI UX design has its merits, it is important to recognize that it is not the ultimate solution for every product or user. The rebellion against intuitive design stems from the belief that complexity, depth, learning, personalization, and delight can be equally valuable in certain contexts. By embracing a more nuanced approach to UI UX design, we can create experiences that cater to a wider range of users, including those who appreciate the challenges and rewards of non-intuitive interfaces.